From the Oregonian April 26, 2010
by Dawn Menken
Our children are precious. We adore them, cherish them and provide for them. So how is it that they can be so cruel? We read about bullying and we wonder, whose kids do these things?
The answer is our kids. It’s not other families. Bullying is in our families, too. Shocking headlines about children who commit suicide because they’re tormented by bullies numb us to the everyday hurtful interactions that are precursors to more dangerous behaviors.
Children reflect behavior they learn at home, in school and in the world at large. In fact, children are frequently more free to say things that most adults self-censor. Here’s an earful:
“You have weird hair.”
“You look like a boy.”
“Your food’s disgusting. Hey, look at this gross food Elijah’s eating!”
“You’re so stupid! You ran the wrong way! Ha, ha ha!”
“You’re a baby. Look, Sam’s crying.”
“You throw like a girl.”
“You can’t play. We have enough people.”
“Don’t you think you’re too old for that?”
That’s just a small sample of the seemingly insignificant remarks one hears daily in the schoolyard. Such common put-downs boost the self-esteem of the speaker and create insiders and outsiders. They’re words that seem of little consequence but deeply hurt, words that declare an order of dominance and enforce behavioral norms.
Children clearly get the message that differences won’t be tolerated. They don’t react for fear of being mercilessly teased. They allow others to define them and the norms of what’s culturally acceptable.
Looking at the statements overheard in one hour at recess tells us about the restricted culture children are creating — or re-creating. They learn quickly: There are strict gender roles to adhere to. There are certain ways of dress and appearance that need to be followed. Kids better be smart and cool. Failure and mistakes are huge humiliations. Avoid unfamiliar foods or cultures. Don’t be emotional or express feelings.
Schools and families that foster a culture that truly values the diverse nature of individuals lay the groundwork for bully-free schools and homes. But championing diversity is no simple feat. Many of us who seek a world of equality and diversity miss how we marginalize our inner diversity.
Ask yourself: Are we a family that values rational thought and feels uncomfortable with emotions? Are we aware how our children tease others for their emotional expression? Do we value only excellence and success? Are we aware that when we give children no room to fail they become increasingly impatient and critical of others?
Are we aware how we might inadvertently uphold certain gender attributes, even subtly, in terms of dress, looks, expectations and behaviors? Do we question our children’s one-sidedness and offer alternative views of the world? Do we help our children use their talents for the good of us all or just encourage them to dominate and excel in the world that they feel most comfortable in? Do we allow and encourage a diversity of opinion and thought, as well as feelings and emotional expression in our homes?
When our child is sad or hurt about something, do we validate that feeling and take it seriously? When our child is angry, do we tell him there’s no reason to be angry, or can we understand and appreciate his feeling even though we might not share it? When our child has an opinion, do we challenge it and inadvertently minimize it? When we as parents speak out strongly and are upset with our children, do we encourage them to also give their view even when it might go against us?
Think about this: If our children feel they cannot speak up to us, can we expect them to stand up to a bully?
Dawn Menken of Portland is a psychotherapist and conflict resolution educator. www.dawnmenken.com
I’m glad this is being talked about a little more within society. Two similar attacks on people are cause stalking (also called gang stalking or multi stalking) and toxic mobbing. Toxic mobbing happens more in the work place – and gets a lot more attention. It is legally recognized and people win law suits sometimes. Cause stalking is much less recognized – large groups of people coordinate an attack against a person – in sometimes extremely subtle ways. A person could be emotionally punched without others in the same room noticing. Different ways of attacking are used for different people – it is tailored to the person. It can involve following the person – and letting the person know they are – in subtle ways which others may not believe or recognize; breaking into homes – shaking up sense of safety; spreading mis-information to character bash; violating space/touch barriers; using all kinds of technology to harass a person and much more… the possibilities are endless. There is a movement to try to get it recognized as a form of stalking – like one-on-one stalking is recognized… but frankly not much is officially recognized at this point by society.
This happened to me and I called the police – who seemed to think I was asking an outer space question. I called the FBI, the CIA, Amnesty International… no one seemed to really get it – either the FBI or the CIA said to talk to local authorities – well that gets no where. An officer refused to even make a report on the breaking and entering because there was not proof. Evaluations from a mental health awareness theater project were stolen – how do you prove that. Roommates and I were robbed in DC and they believed jewelry was stolen – because that makes sense – people like money. I was given a mental health number by the police – even though I was explaining things as sensibly as possible – not mentioning the other odd things that were happening because they surely would not believe that. Many people who complain are just labeled crazy and sent on their way. It does kill. It can be felt as sexual harrassment too – depending on the formula used for the person (I just had a very small amount of that kind of harassment feel with my abuse). I wanted to support my mom as she was dealing with cancer – so I moved – but frankly I could not handle living and functioning anymore where I was anyway. It can run people out of town. It can destroy your ability to function. I would sit in a meeting and be completely unable to function. If I talk to people – most people do not get it or even forget I ever told them. How could I share something so treacherous to me and something so odd and it just be forgotten? Oh yeah, you mentioned that. Good grief – our capacity to see these things is really clouded – maybe because it is so strange? It is invisible and people do not digest it. The people who got it were people who had similar things happen to them. People who have been targets of spiritual abuse for example got it more and accepted it as something that happens. It needs to be recognized officially by society – bullying is recognized more because it is visible. People see the bruises – yet that is not even enough. Toxic mobbing is recognized more for some reason – why not cause stalking? Why can’t we believe that bullying can take subtler forms and be done by adults – which still can kill or have people commit suicide from the abuse? I would sometimes think I cannot see living like this – and often then it would let up a bit. How is it possible a person goes to jail for stealing $100, yet people can kill, sexually harrass, break into houses, abuse, stalk and toxify with such impunity? Are we serious? Is stealing $100 enough to have someone go to jail – yet we are blind to the affects of things like bullying, toxic mobbing, spiritual abuse and cause stalking – that actually kill people? It blows my mind. How do we decide what is relevant in harming others? How did stealing $100 get more offensive than killing? We send out people and spend lots of money to handle that. I appreciate less harm options for intervention – but blind eye is the furthest thing from intervention – that empowers it. Abuse with impunity. Killing with impunity. It passes. Blows my mind.
I remember wondering if a kid was being bullied when I was in grade school – I heard something from someone. What was being done? What was my role – do I follow them? I thought I would, then I heard a teacher was on it and they were chilling out – it is so elusive – was it taken care of? How did they know? I did not even know who the child was – so I felt powerless. How can we be sure? How much did that happen and I just didn’t get it? Didn’t see it? What do we do with it? We need to learn (myself included) more as a society what this stuff is and how we can support the people involved. It is true the longer I felt cause stalking happen to me, after years I see the oppressive spirit coming into me – I want to oppress back. In my mind I call people names more often – it offers a release – even if I still do not truley believe the name I just said to myself is true. Luckily it is lessening and I have more support living with my parents again – so I think I will be able to counter the feelings of being more oppressive myself – but abuse is extremely powerful and can transform me. Dangerous stuff. All the acts of violence – I often wonder how many people were cause stalked – but I guess various kinds of abuse can have different end results. Cause stalking gave me such a desperate feeling – because it can be done by groups of strangers and no one even believes it. Abuse is often justified somehow by the people who do it I have heard – but I was not given a clue as to why it was being done – which adds to its maddening capacity. Communication with me was not a part of the program.
People’s ignorance to the existence of cause stalking is almost too much to bear at times – but I have to deal with that if I ever hope people will believe it does exist. I want to create an awareness flyer, but am not finding anything that really proves it – so I guess it will have to be a bit ambiguous. The first year it was happening – I kept reminding myself that I would have had a hard time believing it was true before it happened to me. I need to remember that now too – it is hard to believe – but the longer we do not see it, the more people will die from it or feel abused or all kinds of negative feelings.